REPORTS OF READING

 

 

Reports LRA n°1


R. Joseph GIKATILA, The secret of David's marriage and Bethsabée, established Hebrew text, translates and presented by Charles Mopsik, Publishing(editions) of the Brightness, 1994. 

This R.J.Gikatila's ( 1248-1325 ) brief treaty, kabbaliste Spanish of big good name, can be considered as an invaluable complement literally on the holiness (Greenfinch, on 1986) which it takes place there so quite to attribute(award), according to HP. Mopsik to same Gikatila. One of the numerous merits of these papers is to establish the existence of a secret doctrine of the sexuality, what allows to verify on this precise point in which measure approach ésotérique things exceeds from a great distance the restrictive speech to which philosophico-theological authorities accustom us sometimes. Although we have not to deal here with a érotologie, no aspect of the relation among the man and the woman(wife) is left in the shadow. The secret of David's marriage and Bethsabée leans mainly on a doctrine of the androgynie préexistencielle of the soul at which the union of the couple aims to restore. The evocation of the adulterous relation among David and Bethsabée then marries of Urie the Hittite allows Gikatila to expose(explain) this other fundamental doctrine which is that of the predetermination of the partners of the couple underlines HP. Mopsik. In other words, in spite of the grave sprain which it(he) commits to the divine Law, David finds in Bethsabée the woman(wife) who of any eternity was promised to him(her). So the "fault" it is transmuée in an act of necessary fulfillment, alone its haste can be incriminated him(her). The main thing is to insist here on the fact that relation man / woman is envisaged in term cosmologique. Their union is equivalent to that of the Sky and the Earth, it reproduces even mysteriously in the microcosmic scale(ladder) the marriage of the Sefira Yessod ( male)(( mate)) and the sefira Malkout ( female). Any meeting is not certainly , in the human plan, hoisted in such summits and in a certain way failure(defeat) or break among the couple is the particular expression of a separation between the entities which they represent. This remarkable text should lead towards a better understanding of the Hebraic vision of the loving report and its metaphysical implications which state a perfect integration of the physical reality in the spiritual world.

Patrick Geay

 


Émir Abd-el KADER, Written spiritual, presented and translated with Arabic by Michel Chodkiewicz, Threshold, Hurt Wisdom, 1994.

These extracts of Kitâb al-Mawâqif (Book(pound) of Stopping places) had been the object of a first publication in 1982, also in the Threshold. This new publishing(edition) will make it, let us hope, easier access. They will doubtless allow a wider public to discover the spiritual dimension which hid itself behind this historic great man that was Émir Abd-el Kader ( 1808-1883 ), at the same moment War leader and diplomat, Boss lit(enlightened) with the Way and exceptional commentator of Ibn Arabî. This collection, preceded by a remarkable introduction and follow-up of plentiful note offer to the readers a series of texts generally rather short, but with which density and power do not let surprise. Number of mysteries is there approached with this constant concern to express answers in a straight(right) and pure language. Often articulated on a verse of the Koran, these Papers give here admirable one example of éxégèse ésotérique, nevertheless totally respectful of the letter of the Book and warning against biased interpretations (your ' wilat). It is not naturally possible to summarize a same education. Several fundamental subjects of the doctrine of Ibn Arabî are there approached of which(whom) that of the uniqueness of the Being (Wahdat al-wujud) which expresses the idea according to which: the essences of creatures are identical to the divine Essence. In other words, that the being of creatures is the being of God, without he is there for all that mix or inherence. One observes also the presence of a conception of the symbolism, moreover identical to that formulated by R.GUÉNON, who sees in the symbol the expression of acts and divine words to lead(drive) the man to the just understanding of things. Such is case notably of the Arabic alphabet, because the combination(overall) of letters establishes(constitutes) structure hidden from the universe as théophanie of some Essence. As for the cleanly said initiatory realization, she(it) peaks in the absolute Servitude ( ubûda ) or any duality faints to leave place with the only reality of the Unique(only). In a lot of consideration, this treaty represents an excellent introduction to the study of the Sufism. It(he) gives evidence besides, in the highest degree, of the continuance of a spiritual lineage akbarienne which, in the doors of XX-th century, will go on until us.

Patrick Geay

 

Charles-André GILIS, The initiatory Doctrine of the Pilgrimage, Al-Bustane, on 1994. IBN ARABI, The thirty six thirty six Koranic certificates of the Unity, translation and Ch-A.GILIS , Al-Bustane's presentation, on 1994. 

It is necessary to greet Publishing(editions) Al-Bustane for the republication of these two essential publications of Ch-A.Gilis appeared respectively in 1982 and in 1984 to the Publishing(editions) of I Œuvre. The first established(constituted) and always establishes(constitutes) an approach without equal of the meaning ésotérique rites of the Pilgrimage in Mecca. As for the second, published first of all under the title: The Koran and the function(office) of Hermès, it was about a presentation of extracts of chap.198 Futûhât al-Makkiyya (The Illuminations of Mecca) of Ibn Arabî, entitled: " The Knowledge of the Breath of the Quite-merciful and its secrets ". We shall make here only give a brief outline of these two remarkable works which during their first publishing(edition) had been almost crossed(spent) under silence. The initiatory Doctrine of the Pilgrimage leans mainly on educations passed on by Ibn Arabî, in particular in him(it,her) chap.72 Futuhat, but also as in all the Ch-A.Gilis's following publications, on the works of R.GUÉNON and M.VÂLSAN. Véritable Omphalos, Mecca represents, according to this study, an Islamic symbol of the Divine Town but also the centre of the human state from which access to the centre To be total him(her,it), represented by Arafat, ultimate station of the Pilgrimage where invisible presence and blessing of the " divine King of the World " becomes updated once the year, is made possible. In cleanly spoken Kaaba, stony building built according to the proportions of the sacred architecture is the receptacle of God's presence on the Earth and Pierre Noire, set in its angle is, concentrates more specially what Islam indicates(appoints) by the Right-hand side of Allâh. Ch-A.Gilis evokes besides in a way diachronique the various states of Kaaba, since the Paradise adamique by way of the reconstruction of the House crowned by Abraham and Ismaël then finally at the time of the Seer Muhammad. So, although Islam represents the last revelation, shown consequently to the extremities of the human cycle, Pilgrimage seems as a purificatory collection allowing those that carry out him(it) reinstatement, at least virtual, of original state, and beyond, realization of the supreme Nearness. On many other points, this work could give place to interesting searches, in particular on the masonic plan, which we shall not miss to begin in the future. 

The thirty six Koranic certificates of the Unity indicate(appoint) the verses of the Koran in which metaphysical Unity ( Tawhid) is asserted. These are followed(logical) by a comment of Ibn Arabî and Ch-A.Gilis's additional notes which come to clarify many difficult passages. As for the precedent, this work of a big doctrinal content can not be the object of a fast presentation. So shall raise(find) we simply some important elements. One will note first of all the big interest of correlations established by Ch-A.Gilis between the number 360, the Fourth sky which in Islam is that of the Sun, governed by the Seer Idris ( Hénoch / Hermès), initiatory Pole of the world, and Royal Art. Real centre of seven global heavens, this sphere of the Sun is also that where from proceeds subtle demonstration symbolized with the number 8 of which 36 is exactly the triangular. Therefore the thirty six certificate ( Tâhll) of the Unity allows to show how this last one shows her presence through the set(group) of the individual forms which represent her own determinations to the universal plan. Secondly, it is advisable to insist on the relation, at once underlined by Ch-A.Gilis, between the notion of At all merciful Breath and that of divine Verb, what calls back(reminds) the particular link which unites the Christ with the Science of the Letters of which he is the holder. It is necessary in that case to repeat here that according to Ibn Arabî, quite complete Existence is not anything else that Words even of Allâh, what allows to understand(include) the existing report between the Breath, Word, Names and Letters which compose this Word. Now, the Quite-merciful ( arRahmân ) is in Islam the principle of the life and the one that maintains, underlines Ch-A.Gilis, by the breath Universal Existence. To finish, the reader will find in the term of this volume an appendix dedicated to the hermetic Seal of the Sun or ' squared magic ' of base 6, understanding(including) 36 compartments. Without revealing all the symbolic aspects of this square, we shall indicate to the passage the strong coherence of the meanings which it(he) covers and in particular, makes him(it) that the addition of the numbers which appear in the horizontal, vertical lines, as well as in the diagonals always gives the sum of of 111 which one knows links with the polar function(office). On several points this dense text must be completed by the reading of another Ch-A.Gilis's work appeared in 1993 (The seven Banners of the Caliphate) which reveals notably the existence of a relation privileged between the number 515 and Idris / Hermès.

Patrick Geay

 

Tinder HAMPÂTÉ BÂ, Jesus seen by a Moslem, Stock, on 1994. 

This small work, introduced by Monseigneur Yapi, postfacé and annotated by Hélène Heckemann (literary heir of the author), consists of two different parts introduced with a diagram conceived and realized with Tinder Hampâté Bâ, representing the symbol of the convergence of three Revelations abrahamiques, and completed in appendix by a text explicatif of Hélène Heckmann. Tinder Hampâté Bâ ( 1900-1991 ), born in Mali, was a follower of Tierno Bokar, the " wise person of Bandiagara ", shaikh of the brotherhood tidjaniya and masterful representative of the high spiritualité Moslem of Black Africa. Through sound work and the life, faithful in the memory and in the education of his(her) boss, leaning on the fundamental values of the Islam, which he recognizes and wishes to recognize as common to all the authentic religions, Tinder Hampâté Bâ wanted the agent of the conciliation of the believers of any confessions and, in particular three big monotheist religions. The first part of the book reproduces a conference given by the author in Niamey (Niger) in 1975, within the framework of an episcopal committee(commission) of relations with the Islam. Through the comparative study of the sacred texts of the Christianity on one hand and the Islam on the other hand, (more particularly those concerning Jesus and Marie), the author attempts to list(count) the points of convergences susceptible to to take away(gain) the membership of two communities and, arousing so a brotherly meeting on a common ground, to suspect them and recognize the deep links of spiritual relationship which unite them and which proceed from the same unique(only) source. It(he) darkens deliberately the points of differences which are anyway perfectly inflexible, in the point of view exotérique where is situated conference, but he invites to follow him(it) beyond forms in an argumentation arithmologique appropriate(clean) to intrigue usefully if it should not be convinced. Second part gathers(reunites) various extracts of conferences and studies ésotériques putting in evidence parallels(parallel lines) visible and less visible than there is possibility of establishing between Christian Pater and Moslem Fatiha. Through the text is outlined acutely a crowned geometry common to the two prayers that one notices fondues in the wave of the same universal movement. Tinder Hampâté Bâ by-passes at least partially the inconveniences of the translation by pressing its argumentation on the study of the roots from Koranic Arabic and from numerous senses(directions) which derive from it. The two parts of this book are the expression of a powerful will of conciliation among the believers of the last two monotheisms abrahamiques, and the big merit of the author is to tempt this conciliation at a level nature of which returns the very difficult company, the conferences - and this book which ensues from it being more specially intended for a public exotérique. Tinder Hampâté Bâ preaches the application of what René Guénon calls " practical tolerance " which takes place on horizontal plan and is totally foreign to the domain of pure Ideas (that one can appear on a vertical axis) and what he presents on the contrary as the indispensable means of preparation for the succession(advent) of the Truth passing by, under varied forms, from the Supreme Source. Some will remain sceptic or will doubtless think that it is there lost and total punishment utopia, the evidence of convergences not being able to hide that of differences, limitations inherent to religious forms and those bound(connected) to the human individuality encouraging rather and for a long time to the adversity. It is necessary to underline all the same intelligence and skill of the speech of the author which confides to the arithmologie or to the science of the roots from classic Arabic of the points which rhetoric would not be enough to light(enlighten). And about arithmologie, let us note that system applied to the French letters, created and taught by Tierno Bokar, can surprise and rests(poses) the interrogation of the origin of the Science. When this last one is unknown, it remains only to judge the tree in his fruits; now, it is easy to notice quickly that a systematic application of the method leads(drives) to interesting results which would justify a more widened study. In conclusion, it is likely that Tinder Hampâté Bâ knew the limits of the reach of its action and he is maybe less useful of épiloguer on the efficiency of this last one than to appreciate a work rich in outlines, in whom(which) every lit(enlightened) believer as well as a lot of initiated will be able to find material(subject) with reflection and with a more detailed search.

Stéphanie LAMARCHE

 

IBN ARABI, The unveiling of the effects of the journey, published(edited) Arabic text, translates and presented by Denis Gril, Publishing(editions) of the Brightness, 1994. 

Denis Gril, who teaches Arabic the University of Provence, is already known for its translation of the Book of the Tree and Four Ibn Arabî's birds (Two Oceans, on 1984) and for its remarkable presentation of the chap. of Futuhat which this last one dedicates to the science of letters (cf. The Illuminations of Mecca, VIII, Sindbad, on 1989), without counting numerous goods(articles) appeared in different specialized reviews. This court treated(handled) as Ibn Arabî concerns essentially the symbolism of the journey as movement since the state of ignorance towards the realization of the science. Such is so the effect of the collection of the pilgrim: access to secrets and to understanding of the hidden sense(direction). So, the sincere interpreter would be the one that passes from a world to the other one, of the enigma in the vision, the darkness in the light. But if this pérégrin is in movement, it is that fundamentally existence has for origin movement; That of the God in the world which It(he) creates and renews all the time. Nothing is consequently immovable, everything in the universe aims by his(its,her) end, returns towards the origin. To every being is inspired, without it(he) is necessarily aware(conscious) of it, the movement which is convenient for him(her) by the unique(only) and real divine Agent. The seers participate also in this universal movement. That is Adam during the exit of the Paradise, of which effect is moreover far from being purely negative, either Hénoch who will be raised(brought up) in the fourth sphere, that of the Sun, to the station of initiatory Pole, they follow all the road which is reserved(distant) them, such Abraham, the Bosom friend of God, which about the sacrifice of his(her) son should also have to travel him(her) since the world of the imagination towards that of the understandable. One will read so with big profit this new translation of Kitâb al-isfâr of which wealth and force will allow to perceive once again the incomparable dimension of the education of Ibn Arabî. The works which pursues D.GRIL on the hermeneutics of the Koran will doubtless bring invaluable information. By waiting for their publications, it is necessary at any rate to be delighted, although it does not go without presenting any dangers, to see multiplying searches on this Boss, everywhere in West.

Patrick Geay

 

Bruno ETIENNE, Abdel Kader, Hatchet, on 1994. 

Here is one of the first important biographies of Émir Abd el-Kader with that appeared almost at the same moment at Fayard. The big merit, besides the systematic inventory of the archives on which she(it) bases himself, is doubtless to grant(tune) a wide place to what was certainly in the heart of the spiritual life of this famous Algerian and also, probably , its military and political action to know, the fastening with traditions ésotériques about the Islam. The route of Émir, its trips in East, its exile in France, its initiation into the Franc - masonry, would be incomprehensible to whom would not like to take into account this fastening. In spite of the indisputable interest of this search one will regret however the subjective, sometimes inconvenient intervention of the author in the reconstruction, very delicate, the "thoughts" of Émir which very often had to see things otherwise that as imagines him(it) B.ETIENNE. How to be able to claim notably that Émir dreamed to build a modern State (p. 181), or still to introduce European technology in East (p. 371)? How to assert that this one corrects same Ibn Arabî's boldnesses (p. 312), when one knows which eminent akbarien was Abd el-Kader? Maybe there was some danger to be wanted so to make a fictitious dialogue with this man outside the common. On the other hand, was it necessary to have appeal to certain concepts of the psychoanalysis to explain such or such aspect of the behaviour(canal) (P. 324) of Émir collectively to M.Chodkiewicz and Ch-A.Gilis's purely spiritual interpretations to what refers repeatedly B.ETIENNE? This obvious contradiction weakens inevitably the approach of this last one it who it mixs(involves) rigorously diverse points of view. The reader is so constantly shaken enter a psycho-pathological perception of the personality of Abd el-Kader (p. 365) and an enthusiasm, rather rare, for the Islam, presented as a chance for France (P. 373). These formulated reserves one has to recognize that this biography reviews a considerable documentary mass and that it allows better to arrest(dread) the true nature of the relations which had this holy knight with our country. Many zones of shadows live(remain) as the links with the Shaikh Abd al-Rahman Illaysh of which one called back(reminded) here reports(connections) with R.GUÉNON, but maybe new discoveries will give us the occasion better to encircle this aspect of things.

Patrick Geay

 

JACOB BOEHME, Of the signature of things, translates from German by Pierre Deghaye, Grasset, on 1995. 

This new and remarkable translation of one of J.Boehme's ( 1575-1624 ) most important papers establishes(constitutes) the first volume of a young collection ( The Sacred Writings) that steers recently Jean-Philippe de Tonnac. It will be much easier so now directly to reach the œuv of this big théosophe which up to here was accessible(approachable) only in partial publishing(editions) or tronquées mostly confidential. Besides, the requiring(demanding) reader will have the possiblité to compare this education, of an indisputable wealth, with presentations and particularly doubtful recoveries of which he is a victim for the XIX-th century. Attempts at F.von Baader or Hegel to make of Boehme a distant ancestor of the German idealism, the resumption of this thesis by E.BENZ, A.KOYRÉ and so many the others else today risk hardly to seem henceforth indefensible. Nobody(no) draws, indeed , of a "evolutionism" to the théosophe and some more an idea, which crosses all the Hegelian thought, of a god in future, taking in the historic temporality. On the contrary, it seems that doctrine inspired by Boehme is the expression of a Christian esotericism and more exactly a spiritual alchemy rooted in the evangelic revelation. On this point, it is advisable moreover to clarify that she(it) represents a sort of Occidental will as for the underlying and real signification of the art alchimique which, apparently, does not have anything to see here with a some chemistry of laboratory. According to Boehme who writes in an apocalyptic perspective, not in front of doubtless not big thing(matter) to Luther, time is close where all which was hidden will be revealed (p. 39). Fundamentally, it is a question of showing how by a second birth the man will be able to reach this stone of the philosophers which he identifies with the angular stone and with the Christ (p. 41). By redrawing process cosmologique by which divine Will gives birth to the world, Boehme insists on the fact that the physical dimension of the being is well the receptacle and God's image, surface on which He signs and prints his hidden mysteries. However, since the Fall this dimension made opaque and darkened, also the supreme vocation of the alchemist is to restore the celestial body of the original man in the simple element which Boehme identifies clearly with the quintessence. By this work, outside and inside will be again gathered(reunited), found paradise. But this work can not come true without the individual dies in himself(itself) and especially whom(that) he gives up definitively its autonomy and its appropriate(clean) will. In terms which call back(remind) strongly the Islamic doctrine of the perfect servitude ( ubûda ), Boehme does not stop criticizing how much it is necessary to give way to the Will of the unique(only) God so that the regenerated man becomes a verb in the Verb (p. 310).

Patrick.Geay

 

 

Return Reception

Next Reports